
Leaving Amish Paradise, the sequel to Trouble in Amish Paradise is now airing in the UK. In it, we follow the continuing saga of Ephraim and Amanda Stoltzfus as well as another couple who have left the Amish, Jesse and Elsie Miller. Spoiler Alert: click the links at the bottom of this post if you want to see it for yourself first before reading my comments.
To quote the caption from BBC2′s website this is a:
“Documentary following the lives of two Amish families leaving the only world they’ve ever known and trying to get to grips with the modern world. The Amish travel by horse and buggy, and dress exactly as their forebears did when they first arrived in America almost 300 years ago. They have countless rules which keep them separate from the modern world, with electric lights, mobile phones, television and radio all forbidden. For those born into this culture, leaving is the biggest decision they’ll ever make.”
And here are a few quotes from the film itself.
“All around the packed church (Charity Christian Fellowship), I see Amish in transition to the modern world. Most of the women have replaced the Amish head covering with simple scarves. Some of the men still dress and shave in the Amish way, while others are in the process of shedding the look. It is full of people just like Elsie and Jesse.”
“See I didn’t need a set of rules anymore to guide my life when I became a Christian… I now have living inside of me God himself who knows right from wrong, and so I don’t need rules.” –Ephraim
“Jesse wants to buy a car, but he’s having trouble selling his buggy. While only Amish would want it, no Amish would buy it off him…. ‘They don’t want to help us to something different than what we were brought up from’.”
“The Amish are taught to obey without question and to conform. At first glance, the congregation of Charity Church doesn’t appear to be all that different to the Amish church that so many of them have come from. Although Charity claims not to have rules like the Amish, they’re lives are governed by what they read in the Bible, and they too, keep their distance from the modern world. But although it might not seem much of a difference, coming to this church is probably the biggest change they’ll ever make in their lives.”
And the ending words from the film:
“But still, the Amish elders see him (Ephraim) as a threat; and not without reason. If this move towards Evangelical Christianity takes hold, it could be the end of the Amish as they are now. But, it could also be the beginning of something new. (credits roll).”
The documentary has been posted on youtube and can be viewed at the links below.
Leaving Amish Paradise:
1 of 4 – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0TU3AYgYlW4
2 of 4 – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn7OwBUEypA
3 of 4 – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SlIQFoUZfOs
4 of 4 – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k32HbZkdNkc
Posted on March 21st, 2011 by Josh Champagne
Filed under: Uncategorized | 4 Comments »